Classic Southern Italian Dining Since 1907
For more than a century, Gargiulo's has welcomed generations of guests to Coney Island for authentic Southern Italian cuisine, warm hospitality, and unforgettable celebrations.
Dinner Menu
Traditional Southern Italian cuisine, fresh seafood, and house specialties.
Wine List
Italian and domestic selections carefully chosen to complement every meal.
Dessert Menu
Classic Italian pastries, cakes, and after dinner favorites.
A Dining Tradition Since 1907
For more than a century, Gargiulo’s Menu has celebrated the traditions of Southern Italian cooking and hospitality. From fresh seafood and delicious pastas to classic Italian desserts and carefully selected wines, our menu showcases the dishes that have made Gargiulo’s a Coney Island dining destination since 1907.
Calamari Racanati
Penne Pasqualina
Homemade Cannoli
Give the Gift of Gargiulo's
Celebrate birthdays, anniversaries, holidays, or any special occasion with a Gargiulo’s gift card.
Experience Gargiulo's Restaurant
Join us for authentic Southern Italian dining in Coney Island, whether you’re planning a family dinner, celebrating a special occasion, or visiting us for the very first time.